Comparing mini SUV and Sedan! Never mind, let me explain. For petrol, I suggest City. Why? Because considering you have driver, most of your time will be spent in the back seat and let me tell you, no car in 10-11L range can beat City's rear seat comfort. And from what I read, Creta's not abundant with space and can beat City!!. So better option will be to go with City. And next, price wise, we should compare Creta S petrol w/ ABS v City VX Petrol which has 2 Airbags + ABS!!
If you ask me, if your city does have hell a lot of potholed roads and you get to drive, then buy Creta, else City!