Tata Zest vs Honda Amaze vs Maruti Dzire vs Hyundai Xcent vs Ford Figo Sedan


Which is the Best Compact Sedan in India


  • Total voters
    292
Joined
Oct 30, 2013
Messages
245
Likes
110
Location
Bangalore
Going through the thread everyone is overly excited about about zest, although the features are good I feel the real test will be in a years time and that will be the right time to buy this vehicle.

Dzire is a very popular time tested model
 
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
327
Likes
297
Location
New delhi
Side view mirrors of zest have electric adjust but no electric folds even on XT .[surprise] i went to get evaluation of my tata indigo Glx 2006 and was shocked by the price they offered [frustration]
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Messages
474
Likes
562
Location
Bangalore
Today, I had a test drive of both top end Petrol Revotron Zest and top end Diesel Zest back-to- back at a promotional even organized by TML at Forum mall, Koramangala, Bangalore. They both were silver coloured vehicles. And here is my comaprision after driving both of them back-to-back.
I am very happy to see a Tata product improved in such a great heights in all aspects.

First I drove petrol variant, and the initial feelings are:
1) interiors,equipment levels and plastics are at par with any other company like Ford, Honda and Hyundai.
2) steering is auper light and steering grip is superb.
3) clutch is super light and the seating position is very good. Seats are super soft and provide enough thigh support and shoulder support.
4) HMI on the on-screen 5-inch touch infotainment from Harman is ultimate. There are just a few little commands which you need to memorize to order your zest to do what you want. Then it obeys the master very well.
5) Audio system from Harman - JBL speakers in particular sound amazing. THere are 4 component speakers (ie., 4 sets of woofers and corresponding tweeters) makes the cabin amazingly clear.
6) Cabin itself is super silent in petrol and a little of engine sound heard in diesel zest only if keenly heard.
7) Engine vibrations are NIL at steering and gear knob, both in petrol and diesel.
8) I can feel the difference of the three modes viz., city mode, eco mode and sport modes in petrol variant. And yes, these modes are only present in Revotron variants (petrol variants) only
9) Overall fit and finish of interiors is top notch and the door shut lines are very consistent and very minimal.
10) ride and handling is superb and swallows any sorts of bumps the road ahead throws you.
11) Features list is just awesome and the cool part is that corona ring around the projector headlamps (only on top-ends and switches on when Zest is parked) and the LED tail lamps looks pretty cool and make it stand out from its competetion.
12) Rear bench comfort is very good for three adults.
13) Paint jobs are awesome and Zest feels very premium
14) Finally, heard it through the boys at the promotion that Zest will not be sold to the fleet operators and is the first pure family car!!! Nice move by tata motors to clean up its image.

One slight lower side i found with diesel zest is that the gear shifts are little hard when compared to its petrol brother.
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2013
Messages
1,774
Likes
2,274
Location
Coimbatore
Recently did test drive of the Tata Zest with Guhan and Stingray 91.
My review of the Tata Zest from a decently long enough Test drive:

First Impressions: The new dealership for Tata cars is built on Avinashi road here in Coimbatore. There was a Zest in Silver color parked in front of the showroom. Looks quite European and stylish in flesh. There were other Tata cars in there such as Vista and Nano. But it was the Zest which was the crowd puller. Inside the showroom was a Blue one, which was simply fabulous looking. The more I looked at it, the more I was eager to experience it.

Build and strength: I opened the door and closed it, to get a fel of the build. The closing "thud" sound was quite acceptable that shows it is built quite well, at par with Honda, Hyundai and Maruti standards. But the door and bonnet metal seems to be a bit thinner than Maruti Suzuki DZire and Honda Amaze. But given that the Vista recently scored 3 stars in the NCAP crash tests, I assume that the Zest will also be in the same league and will be safe enough.
7/10

Design: Like I said, the Zest is absolutely fabulous looking with very European looks. Especially in Bright shades like the Blue and Red. The roof is a bit tall and the boot is short and stubby. But still, the proportions are decent and uniquely eye-catching. It turned heads everywhere along the way. Tata has done a great job, given that how difficult it would be to integrate a seamless boot to a tall and big hatch body! Alloys look good too.
The projectors with LED ring surrounding it is absolutely fabulous!
There are L-shaped LED strips also around the fog lamps.
8/10

Interior design and features: The moment I sat down in the driver seat, it was hard for me to believe that I am sitting actually in a Tata car! The design is the best among rivals and the quality was much better than any other Tata and the Honda Amaze. But still the Hyundai xcent has best quality.
If you inspect closer, under the door handles and steering console, there are some minor fit and finish issues. It's not a big issue though.
The steering wheel of the Zest is very stylish and European. The Center console with the Piano black and Faux Aluminium plastics is simply awesome. The audio unit is a touchscreen through which the Automatic climate control, "Follow- me headlamps" timer and other essential bits can be controlled. A very useful and nicely working reverse sensor is also provided. There is a fantastic Bluetooth connection and Voice control system too!
Power Windows and Electrically adjustable Mirrors are standard on most of the variants. Alloy wheels are standard on all variants, albeit the design differs for lower variants.
The boot is fully opened automatically when you pull the boot-release lever as it is spring loaded (Very convenient). ACC can be controlled by the usual set of buttons and knobs below the the Touchscreen unit also. The AC was powerful enough to make me and my friends to shiver.
There is no Rear AC but I think there is no need of it, given that the front blowers are powerful enough. But there is no "seatbelt height adjuster", which will be annoying for tall people. I felt happy as there is no "Start-stop push button" on offer. I find it silly and a feature that makes us lazy to twist even a key! (Have humans become that lazy??) The key hole is LED lit to help in the dark.
Overall I was very convinced and happy about the interiors. Fantastic job Tata.
8/10

Practicality: The glovebox is H-U-G-E! The boot has 390 liters capacity, which makes it just 10 liters less than the Amaze and much bigger than the Dzire.
Problem is there is ONLY ONE cupholder in the car! This may be not good as long distance travelers always need at least 4 bottles of water. But there are seat covers with integrated bottle holders offered as genuine accessories by Tata. (Hilarious)!
7/10

Only the Manual XT Diesel variant was available for test drive.
the key was of good quality.

Refinement: As we start the engine, there is some very small vibrations. But as the engine idles, the vibrations and noise reduces to almost nil! Even as revs increase, there is no vibes. The noise is bare minimum. Absolutely no suspension or road noise either. It is only when the revs increase above 3000rpm, the noise becomes clearly audible. Tata has done a clearly fantastic job in terms of noise insulation and refinement.
9/10

Space and Comfort: Tata cars have always been spacious and comfortable for everyone. The Zest is no different as it is based on the most spacious hatchback in it's segment, the Vista. The all-new "Rugby shoulder seats" are very comfortable and offer fantastic support for long drives. So are the rear seats that are very comfortable and supportive. There is good space in the rear even if I am seated in the driver seat, given that I have longer legs.
There is no rear seat-armrest, which I feel is quite a pinch on long drives and also given that all it's rivals have it. Also I personally felt that the seats are a bit hard compared to the Dzire's seats.
8/10

Audio: Now since there are lot of people interested in the high-tech entertainment system and audio, here is what I got to experience.
The system has been designed by Harmann and it sounds AWESOME!! There is crystal clear sound quality and absolutely no noise! Best enjoyed with heavy Bass songs. The resolution and responsiveness of the display is also good. The audio quality is helped further by the impeccable refinement and insulation. This is the best Entertainment system I have ever experienced!
9/10

Performance: Since I already drive a Multijet powered car, the bottom-end power is what I have got used to. This is the same Quadrajet (Multijet of FIAT) which is being extensively used for various Maruti Suzuki, Tata, Chevrolet and FIAT cars. This is a bit more smoother to drive in the Zest though, thanks to the refinement.
I was surprised as I increased the revs. The responsiveness is a bit better than other Multijet powered cars. It puts out 88.8bhp and torque of 200Nm @ 1750-3000rpm The Zest can take speeds a bit lower than what speeds my car can take in a gear! Tata has tuned this engine for better responsiveness and low-end power and that is quite evident.
The acceleration is linear and there is very little of that "Turbo-kick" associated with other Multijet cars. This makes city driving easier. after 2000 rpm, the turbo comes into full power and there is a rapid progress in speed. (Typical Mulitijet) The responsiveness increases as it nears 1800rpm. Speeds of 80-140 can be effortlessly maintained all day long.
This engine is quite a very good one and fits all purposes. It's only when it comes to outright low-speed responsiveness, this engine doesn't have the peppiness of the Honda Amaze. Tata's Quadrajet 90 is best as an effortless cruiser.
8/10

Transmission: I expected the clutch and gearbox to be heavy as other Tata cars. But to my surprise, the Clutch was lighter than Maruti's clutch! The gearbox also was light enough, but a bit vague and not as good as that of Dzire or Amaze. Quick overtakes were quite easy with good responsiveness and light clutch.
But the clutch felt quite weird as it is slow to re-engage as we take our foot off it. The gearbox lever also had a weird tendency to move back and forth when we change a gear and accelerate again. Seems like that was just a prototype and hope the production (customer) cars get it rectified.
8/10

Ride quality and handling: Now this is where the Zest clearly thrashes it's every rival. The ride is absolutely stable and smooth on almost every surface. There is only a slight pitching on long undulating patches. The suspension and the 15 inch wheels absorb anything and everything really well! There is a considerable bit of roll when cornering because of the tall stance, but it is not unsettling or uncomfortable.
The steering is now electric-assisted and it is a bit lighter and easier than the Dzire's. There is good amount of feel and feedback also, in higher speeds. It can effortlessly negotiate city traffic and at the same time can cruise at speeds on highways. This ride-handling balance is very much similar to the Dzire and the best in this segment, according to me!
8/10

Safety: Inertia-reel equipped seatbelts, ABS, Corner Stability System and Dual airbags are standard on the XT variant. There is also a lower XMS variant which focusses on safety and provides all the above safety features, but loses some of the entertainment and convenience features. Given that the Vista has scored 3 stars in NCAP crash test, the Zest is also expected to deliver similar safety.
7/10

Price: The Petrol variants of the Zest range from 5.5 to 7.03 lacs.
The Diesel variants range from 6.6 to 8.2 lacs.
(On-road prices Coimbatore)
The prices make the Zest the most affordable and best Value compact sedan, compared to its's rivals.
9/10

Verdict: The Zest provides the ride-handling and comfort of Dzire, the performance and space almost equal to the Amaze, the equipment list and value of the Xcent. Although there are some pinches like absence of armrest, rear AC and lazy low speed responsiveness, the Zest provides the ultimate package for a Compact sedan and according to me, is the best in it's segment. Period. Kudos to Tata and congrats too, for creating a fantastic car.
8/10

Now all depends on the service and dealership of Tata Motors in making this product successful.

Thank you for reading my review.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Joined
May 23, 2014
Messages
607
Likes
595
Location
coimbatore
Recently did test drive of the Tata Zest with Guhan and Stingray 91.
My review of the Tata Zest from a decently long enough Test drive:

First Impressions: The new dealership for Tata cars is built on Avinashi road here in Coimbatore. There was a Zest in Silver color parked in front of the showroom. Looks quite European and stylish in flesh. There were other Tata cars in there such as Vista and Nano. But it was the Zest which was the crowd puller. Inside the showroom was a Blue one, which was simply fabulous looking. The more I looked at it, the more I was eager to experience it.

..

Thank you for reading my review.
Dj,thanks for sharing the review,
The gear box was not notchy , its because when you decelerate the synchronizer slips out slightly so you can change to next gear, at that time if you try to pull the stick out of gear position,the gear easily comes go neutral even if you don't apply clutch, but if you accelerate without pulling the synchronizer gets back to position by pulling gear leaver back to point, the issue faced in zest is the springs hold the gear leaver is not adjusted correctly, it can be rectified after the service, you can remember the executive told us the car is nnt serviced yet even after 5k kms
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
May 1, 2011
Messages
1,765
Likes
342
Location
delhi
Booked tata zest xmx version at Autovikas Sales, motinagar for 6.06 lacs

Imp: Malwa motors ,rohini is taking extra Rs 6000 in registration ( 33000 vs 26000 at autovikas). When i told malwa they immediatelky agreed to reduce it.

But i booked at autovikas

Had to bow to family pressure and leave blue/red colour and settle for beige
 
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
3,171
Likes
829
Location
Ahmedabad
Booked tata zest xmx version at Autovikas Sales, motinagar for 6.06 lacs

Imp: Malwa motors ,rohini is taking extra Rs 6000 in registration ( 33000 vs 26000 at autovikas). When i told malwa they immediatelky agreed to reduce it.

But i booked at autovikas

Had to bow to family pressure and leave blue/red colour and settle for beige
Many congratulations viabhav. when is the delivery expected?
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2013
Messages
1,774
Likes
2,274
Location
Coimbatore
More pics...
 

Attachments

Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
427
Likes
281
Location
Coimbatore
After Indica, Zest looks very promising car from the TATAs. Though I haven't checked out in person, both the interior and exterior photographs look amazing. Hope the dealers are geared up to handle after sales support i.e., service without which its difficult to get customers their way however good the product be.

But, I voted for Dzire considering it is more proven car and VFM as well.
Saw ZEST in person this weekend at Fun Mall, Coimbatore. The first impression, was WOW & my 11 year old son also said the same. I found the car appealing from all angles - both exterior and interior. Nothing like any of the TATA cars we have seen in the past. The photos give an impression of a bigger car, but in person sub-4m size shows - it looks much shorter than photographs. Nevertheless no complaints on aesthetics. On the interiors too, plastics and upholstery quality felt very good. But best part is dashboard and steering - both definitely look stunning as well as solid - like European cars (not Japanese).

I couldn't TD the car & hence reserving my comments on driving dynamics.
Wish I could change my vote to ZEST.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Messages
474
Likes
562
Location
Bangalore
Booked tata zest xmx version at Autovikas Sales, motinagar for 6.06 lacs

Imp: Malwa motors ,rohini is taking extra Rs 6000 in registration ( 33000 vs 26000 at autovikas). When i told malwa they immediatelky agreed to reduce it.

But i booked at autovikas

Had to bow to family pressure and leave blue/red colour and settle for beige
Congratulations, Vaibhav for your beige beauty.
 
Thread Starter #240
Joined
Jan 25, 2013
Messages
1,523
Likes
1,531
Location
Hyderabad
Compact Sedan sales comparision in august

MARUTI SUZUKI Swift DZire

Sold 19129 units in August 2014

Honda Amaze

Sold 9198 units in August 2014

Hyundai Xcent

Sold 5509 units in August 2014

TATA ZEST

Sold 2671 units in August 2014

1st position MARUTI SUZUKI Swift Dzire

2nd Position HONDA Amaze

3rd Position Hyundai Xcent

4th position TATA ZEST
 
Top Bottom