Re: Maruti Suzuki's Ciaz Facelift Coming in 2017
I'll answer "bottom to top".
Yeah, you are correct. Because of Verna's lifeless steering, I got involved in 10000 accidents, died a Million times and am afraid to cross 25 kph speed
. Jokes apart, I expect anyone criticizing Fluidic Verna to have driven it at least around 10% of my Verna's Odo (which is > 58,000km). Fair enough ?
Hyundai's 1.6 CRDi has 126 bhp in stock. If you search on "tuning of this engine", you wouldn't find much reports. Why ? "You don't need it" could be a possible answer.
I got the Ex Showroom costs from respective manufacturers web site; for Bangalore. S-Cross prices came from Nexa site.
I'm not interested in glorifying Verna. But, when certain products are glorified, it catches my eye. Sometimes, I respond with a hope to help a potential buyer make an informed decision.
PS: BTW, I am pretty sure, if any manufacturer other than Maruti had launched Ciaz, it would have been a failure. Linea, Manza, Sunny, Scala, Punto, Fabia all come to my mind. Hummmm
Thats unfair , Ciaz is a compelling product , engine power aside
They have a decent AT and excellent legroom at a good price
Maintenance is on the lower side too
Fiat 1.6 MJD is one of the most acclaimed enthusiast engines around, its mod friendly and very popular with good reason. So much so , that its direct competitor in terms of performance is usually the 1.8 TDI in Octavia since it surpasses the engines this side of 20L thanks to sheer torque
If it had a decent AT or even DCT/DSG, it would have been a hit
Manual+high price+ uninspiring looks/stance is what kills the S Cross sales
Ive mentioned before, steering is a very personal preference but at higher speeds, the need for hydraulic steering is very important to prevent oversteer in terms of emergency maneuvers, not saying this isnt possible in Hyundai steerings but it requires more judgement and driver skill
Ive driven my friends Grand i10 and my Innova enough to know this , the ghat section is scarier with Grand i10 since steering feedback is very less but on my first drive of Innova , I was very confident of tackling the ghats
As for "You dont need it", no engine needs it , its purely upto user preference but hey if anyone ever needs to go down that route/intends to. VW TDI,TSI and Fiat MJDs are the easiest and safest to mod given the amount of trial and error conducted on them
As for prices, Ive posted Mumbai (Central) prices and have the price lists at my brothers house
About the following cars-
Linea, Manza, Sunny, Scala, Punto, Fabia
Linea and Punto- Good engine and build but poor driving position and weird ergonomics.
Manza- Good features but tonnes of niggles at launch, some members here have had a good experience with it , some havent
Sunny- Excellent engine, best in class legroom , ancient cabin and long throw clutch and gearbox. My cousin swears by it even if he had problems with his dealer in Pune intially.
Scala- Never took off for some reason , surprising since Duster is more popular than Terrano.(Same platform, engine etc)
Fabia- Excellent build but poor reliability and after sales. Engine was also nowhere near its cousin the Polo and hence was discontinued.
Ciaz- Excellent rear seat comfort, good pricing and features but very low engines compared to the competition. City is its main competitor but Ciaz is more spacious.
Also Im not glorifying anything, just stating the obvious after TD of all the cars and multiple views of others. Not saying any product is good or bad. This segment is very complicated, all cars offer very different feel and target different people. None is exactly better than the other.
BTW dont take this in an offensive way, just a discussion of personal preference nothing more.
Sorry if OT