Hello friends just logged on to Automotiveindia and this is my first post .
Let me start by stating that this discussion on Thar vs Gurkha has what has brought me here .
I am an avid offroader and have been doing it for the last four years .
More importantly I am also an owner of the Gurkha Trax for the last 3 years.
I have been arranging Offroad events around Mumbai and I was fortunate enough to have been called by Force Motors to test their New Upgraded Trax Gurkha.
I have written a detailed account of my experience with the new vehicle and you could google " Pre-release Test ride of the New Gurkha " to get a hang of what is expected form the New Gurkha .
I own a Nissan Patrol I 6 3.2 Litres , a 4wd Scorpio mHawk and a Tata Telcoline 4x4 backie . I have extensively driven the Mahindra Thar and the Tata Xenon 4wd .
Since the discussion Thar vs Gurkha , I vote solidly for Gurkha .
Heres why :
I would compare it to the Thar very soon in my next write up so that we could be clear as to what we have in terms of comforts ,spares ,costs etc.
MY LOYAL COMPANION
![final my gurkha.jpg](/forums/data/attachments/70/70390-dfd2f7c2c636572d7d6d5c22dbd7cb84.jpg)
Let me start by stating that this discussion on Thar vs Gurkha has what has brought me here .
I am an avid offroader and have been doing it for the last four years .
More importantly I am also an owner of the Gurkha Trax for the last 3 years.
I have been arranging Offroad events around Mumbai and I was fortunate enough to have been called by Force Motors to test their New Upgraded Trax Gurkha.
I have written a detailed account of my experience with the new vehicle and you could google " Pre-release Test ride of the New Gurkha " to get a hang of what is expected form the New Gurkha .
I own a Nissan Patrol I 6 3.2 Litres , a 4wd Scorpio mHawk and a Tata Telcoline 4x4 backie . I have extensively driven the Mahindra Thar and the Tata Xenon 4wd .
Since the discussion Thar vs Gurkha , I vote solidly for Gurkha .
Heres why :
- The Gurkha has a lineage .It was first designed at the FML ,erstwhile Bajaj Tempo by Dr.Robert Bacher the Co-CEO from the Mercedes side since Bajaj Tempo had a tie up with Merecedes at that time .
- The Gurkha derives form the G wagen literally . It has a tubular chassis ,which no Indian vehicle has ,which has an extreme flex. The front IFS is a very sturdy Hanomag derived Suspension ,extremely rugged and has never failed me despite the extreme uses we put it too. The rear axle is a W460 MB derived rated at 4 ton ,virtually indestructible. Whereas the concept of Differential lockers is relatively new , the Gurkha boasted front and rear differential lockers way back 10 years ago. Add to that the rugged engine ready to take on the worst of India fuels , a massive GC of 230 mm and a custom snorkel. The gear ratio at the rear axle is 4.89:1 which gives you loads of torque at lower RPM for that "crawl". Above all the Gurkha is the only vehicle which has a divorced transfer case .
- It has the least overhang and the best approach angle comparable to any European or American SUV. The ramp break over angle is superb and so also the gradeability.
- I can do an extreme offroading event at Chennai and drive back home to Mumbai in comfort with my family in a hard top Gurkha which has a stock A/c.power steering and power brakes. Could you do that with a custom Thar ?
- The Gurkha has the best water fording capabilities due to the optimal positioning of its engine components, mimimalisitic electronics and a snorkel . During a bizarre offroading event at pavana lake we managed to push the Gurkha half windscreen down the lake and came out unscathed.
I would compare it to the Thar very soon in my next write up so that we could be clear as to what we have in terms of comforts ,spares ,costs etc.
MY LOYAL COMPANION
![final my gurkha.jpg](/forums/data/attachments/70/70390-dfd2f7c2c636572d7d6d5c22dbd7cb84.jpg)