Re: The Story of Tata's Epic Journey from Trucks to Aria
I think both Ratan Tata & Mistry needs to be credited for the way TML has grown in the past years. We all know how TML slumped from #3 position in PV segment to #6 and the efforts the management team has done to revive the fortunes.
You are right, Karl, Tim & Pratap joined when Ratan Tata was the chairman. We should also understand that since Karl's unfortunate demise, it was Mistry who was heading the TML ship and personally i feel that he did a good job and only recently Guenter Butschek took over the mantle. But i will not say that it is Mistry who is responsible for the current success but at the same time you cannot erase his name from the records.
Guys, posting after a long time.
Seems this is not the best time for the entire Tata Group. Need to discuss something important with you people. Need to get some answers.
What Cyrus Mistry done to TML ? Has he done anything exceptional for the turn around of the company ? New products Zest/Bolt/Tiago were designed and developed completely under his tenure ?
If I'm not wrong key factors for today's focus shift in Tata Motors is due to Pratap Bose, Tim Leverton and Late Karl Slym, all were appointed during Ratan Tata's tenure. Mayank Pareek came under Mistry's tenure. If Tata Motors had achieved standalone profits, it is due to improved market conditions in the CV segment and a new PV product line up. I do remember articles saying Mistry's actions on vendors and QC activities within TML which is great. But tell me whether Mistry has done something exceptional in TML turn around. These developments were in the pipeline before Mistry's arrival and should continue even after he is out of TML.
Just trying to find answers after seeing some tweets and reports bashing Ratan Tata and giving full credit to Mistry for TML's current position. I may be wrong. Please correct me with your comments here
Seems this is not the best time for the entire Tata Group. Need to discuss something important with you people. Need to get some answers.
What Cyrus Mistry done to TML ? Has he done anything exceptional for the turn around of the company ? New products Zest/Bolt/Tiago were designed and developed completely under his tenure ?
If I'm not wrong key factors for today's focus shift in Tata Motors is due to Pratap Bose, Tim Leverton and Late Karl Slym, all were appointed during Ratan Tata's tenure. Mayank Pareek came under Mistry's tenure. If Tata Motors had achieved standalone profits, it is due to improved market conditions in the CV segment and a new PV product line up. I do remember articles saying Mistry's actions on vendors and QC activities within TML which is great. But tell me whether Mistry has done something exceptional in TML turn around. These developments were in the pipeline before Mistry's arrival and should continue even after he is out of TML.
Just trying to find answers after seeing some tweets and reports bashing Ratan Tata and giving full credit to Mistry for TML's current position. I may be wrong. Please correct me with your comments here
You are right, Karl, Tim & Pratap joined when Ratan Tata was the chairman. We should also understand that since Karl's unfortunate demise, it was Mistry who was heading the TML ship and personally i feel that he did a good job and only recently Guenter Butschek took over the mantle. But i will not say that it is Mistry who is responsible for the current success but at the same time you cannot erase his name from the records.